Claims     Below is a list of Insurance companies and their contact information. You may also file your claim online by clicking on the company's name. If your insurance company is not listed let us know so we can add it to our list.     Acuity 1-800-242-7666  Allmerica  1-800-628-0250  Allied  1-800-282-1446  Allstate Insurance 1-800-547-8676 / 1-888-859-3946 (Fax )  American Family  1-800-374-1111  Atlantic Mutual  1-800-945-7461  Auto-Owners Insurance  1-517-323-1200 / 1-517-323-8796 (Fax )  Bituminous  1-800-475-4477  Central Mutual Insurance  1-800-877-2233 / 1-800-877-2293 (Fax)  Chubb  1-800-252-4610 / 1-800-300-2538 (Fax)  Cinncinati  513-870-2000  Citizens  1-866-411-2742  CNA  1-877-262-2727  Cotton State  1-800-457-1658 / 1-800-341-2467 (Fax)  Encompass  1-800-588-7400  Farm Bureau     770-922-3566 / 770-785-9170 (Fax)  Farmers  1-800-435-7764  Fidelity National  1-800-220-1351  Fireman's Fund   1-888-347-3428  Foremost Insurance Co.  1-800-527-3907  Grange  1-800-445-3030  Harleysville  1-800-892-8877  Hanover Insurance  1-800-628-0250 / 1-800-399-4773 (Fax)  Homesite Insurance  1-800-466-3748 / 1-877-273-2984 (Fax)  Horace Mann  1-800-999-1030  Liberty Mutual Insurance  1-866-542-2287 / 1-866-791-7490 (Fax)  Metlife  1-800-854-6011 / 1-866-947-0587 (Fax)  Nationwide Insurance  1-888-460-3908 / 1-866-716-9757 (Fax)  OneBeacon  1-877-248-4968  Ohio Casualty  1-800-366-6446  Safeco  1-800-332-3226 / 1-888-268-8840 (Fax)  Selective  1-866-455-9969  Shelter  1-800-743-5837  Southern Mutual Insurance  1-800-226-1919 / 1-706-549-7855 (Fax)  State Farm Insurance  1-866-443-7556 / 1-877-732-6556 (Fax)  The Hartford  1-800-843-7006 / 1-866-804-3764 (Fax)  Travelers  1-800-252-4633 / 1-866-680-3951 (Fax)  United Property & Casualty  1-800-861-4370  USAA  1-800-531-8722 / 1-800-531-8669 (Fax)